Release Dates: 8 Mile – November 6, 2002
Get Rich or Die Tryin’ – November 9, 2005
Production Companies: 8 Mile – Universal Pictures/Imagine Entertainment
Get Rich or Die Tryin’ – Paramount Pictures, along with Interscope/Shady/Aftermath Films and MTV Films
It’s been a long time coming. I had told myself to do this in the past. Why had I not done it? I don’t know but I am finally doing it.
There is so much I could say about these two films. They both came out at the height of Eminem and 50 Cent’s popularities. They both came out in a certain timeframe, which I am not sure if it was a coincidence or intentional. Then again, I recall reading that “8 Mile” was initially supposed to be released in the summer of 2002 but was delayed until the fall of that year. And finally, these films are pseudo-biopics of the leading actors. Why did I call them “pseudo-biopics”? Because their life stories were the basis but not really the actual stories. If anything, the movies are fiction but also have some references to their life, at least to a point.
However, there are differences between the two films. Let me start by talking about “8 Mile.”
So this film has Eminem playing a character named Jimmy Smith but goes by “Rabbit” as that is his rap name. Being that Eminem is from Detroit, a lot of the film was set and shot in 8 Mile Road and was also set in 1995. I think it was set in that time because Em had been on the battle rapping circuit at that point before he got signed years later. So he has a group of friends who support him but he has problems of his own, such as a girlfriend leaving him and lying about being pregnant. He moved back in with his mother, who is dating a guy with whom Rabbit went to school. Oh, and there is a rival crew of rappers and thugs who have issues with Rabbit and his crew, along with a young woman who catches Rabbit’s eye.
Eminem impressed me a bit with his acting ability, but in a lot of ways, I am not sure if he is really playing himself or a character. I can’t say what he’s really like but there were some parts that felt like he was playing himself but at the same time playing a character. Accord to IMDB trivia, Eminem said that personal history would limit the storytelling and characterization, but playing a character would be unrestricted in his performance. It’s a lot more than I could say about his character in “The Wash,” but that was more of a cameo at best.
What really stood out, in my opinion, was Curtis Hanson’s (RIP) direction. It was clear that he went all in when it came to the rap battle scenes, he started an improv battle among some rappers who auditioned and the three best would go up against Eminem, who mimed his battles because he had to save his voice for the scripted scenes. I recall seeing something like that on the DVD extras way back when.
Interestingly enough, I was also impressed by some of the rappers who did the battles, as well as other freestyling scenes. A couple of rappers who appeared were Obie Trice and the late Proof (of D12), whom Eminem was cool with and had signed to his label at the time this was filmed.
As for “Get Rich or Die Tryin’,” well, this one is a different case. Not that it was meant to be exactly like “8 Mile,” but because 50 Cent was involved in criminal activity before becoming a rapper, some sources have said that it was “75% accurate” to 50’s life story. Of course, this wasn’t a straight-up biopic of 50’s life. If anything, this felt more like a hood movie and a gangster movie with the rapping subplot being something the main character, Marcus, pursuing while being a gangster (or is it “gangsta”?).
If I have to treat this as a fictional take or a fictional story, this movie is fine for what it is. I felt like I was watching something like “Juice” or “Menace II Society,” or probably a much better version of “Hot Boyz,” which says a lot considering how bad that film was.
I felt like 50 acted more like himself this time. I am not sure if this film was supposed to kick off his acting career but after this, he mostly did straight-to-video films and played supporting roles in other films because he hadn’t had lead roles in theatrical films after this. I am not sure if “All Things Fall Apart” was released in theaters but that film felt more like a passion project for him.
I will give both films credit for the soundtracks. With “8 Mile” taking place in 1995, it was interesting to hear Mobb Deep, The Notorious B.I.G, Naughty By Nature, and I was intrigued to hear “Gotta Git Mine” by MC Breed and 2Pac in one scene. You only get snippets of Eminem’s songs in the film, at least until the credits. As for GRoDT, you get a lot of 50 songs but I’ll give it that they were supposed to be what 50’s character wrote and performed because it didn’t explicitly state when the film was set.
As for anything else, I would probably say “8 Mile” was the better film. I know that “Get Rich or Die Tryin'” has its fans and I didn’t mind the film but when comparing the two, “8 Mile” was superior because Eminem really did his best in what is likely his only film role and the director did what he could to make the film work. Plus, the script worked with some of Em’s life elements implemented while incorporating some other elements to make it feel like a fictional story than a biopic. GRoDT, on the other hand, I never claimed to be an expert on 50’s life but I am not sure how much is accurate, especially subplots involving a Colombian gang and stuff. If one was to treat it like a fictional crime story, then it’s fine, I suppose.
I had seen “8 Mile” before but it had been years but until I decided to do this post, I had never seen “Get Rich or Die Tryin'” in its entirety.
What also separates the two was that “8 Mile” was the bigger hit. It had an overall gross of more than $240 million while GRoDT barely made its budget back. I think that one was a bigger hit on video and developed a cult following over the years. Personally, I enjoyed both films but I treat them as their own things.
8 Mile – 4/5
Get Rich or Die Tryin’ – 3/5